This one makes me angry.
So many of us in the bay area have been criticizing the president for his lack of national, coordinated response to the coronavirus. As a left of center human – I tend to agree with that sentiment. Hyperlocalism doesn’t really help the situation.
Thursday I watch the governor‘s brief about the state of the pandemic. The state is divided up into five regions based on hospital reciprocity agreements and mutual aid. The governor states that four out of five regions will likely need to go into lockdown in the next week or so. He singled out the bay area highlighting that we would likely be OK through the bulk of December.
Not wanting to be outdone by a politician and making laws - three counties in the bay area decide to jump the gun and lock down tomorrow. A few more lockdown early next week. Some decide to follow the state order and lock down when Sacramento deems they should.
The lack of coordinated messaging and cooperation between local municipalities in the state has been frustrating. We’ve been through three or four different ways to classify risk. Crossing county borders have significantly different rules.
As someone who thinks “follow the science“ this haphazard approach is wearing thin. Why doesn’t Sacramento just add an additional tier and mandate that all of the municipalities follow it once they meet specific criteria requiring additional quarantine measures?
Some good points.
I think that human nature, as demonstrated during this pandemic, plays a role in the large region effect as opposed to county effect. I'm guessing that the counties that 'jumped the gun' did so for a variety of reasons, one might be that they were worse off locally, or perhaps had a more proactive health coordinator who chose more caution than others.
On the human nature side, if one county has a lockdown, how many of the residents of that county might go to the neighboring county which isn't locked down, carrying their greater percentage of infection rates with them? If you have to travel too far, you might not be so inclined to make a 200 mile trek as opposed to a 5-10 mile trek.
There's a lot at play, and 10-15 second sound bites could be easily used to malign a decisionmaker intent on doing the right thing, as we've seen happen numerous times during this pandemic.