Questions on Car Hauler/Cargo trailers

jt2

Eschew Obfuscation
Backstory (actual questions below): Bought some property a couple of years ago in the foothills with a long-term plan to relocate there once my wife retires. The plan has become a bit more fluid as she can work remote indefinitely now. Part of the plan is building my dream garage, a 2800 square foot garage/shop. It is nearing completion and concurrently thinking of putting our current main residence on the market now given the uncertain outlook of the Bay Area over the next couple of years. We may rent a small place down here for a while, or pull the trigger and move up the hill. We’ll see.

Before I list the San Ramon house, I need to get some stuff out of here to make the place more presentable, including a couple of cars (one basket case and another that I’d rather not drive on the highway for that distance), a couple of bikes (one basket case), workbenches, huge table saw, toolboxes, etc.

So I figure I need a trailer of some kind. Rental is not an attractive option, as when we make the run up there, we tend to stay a few days before heading back down. And it will take multiple trips over a couple of months period. Then there’s the eventual move of the rest of the household. Once the process is done I’ll either keep it to fetch future automotive projects, or maybe sell it.

I’ve been looking at some listings and am down to either an open or enclosed car hauler trailer. Tow vehicle is a F-150 with a 11,200lb rating so weight isn’t a huge concern.

I like the idea of an enclosed trailer for the non-car stuff, but the added bulk of it will making storing it a PITA when not in use. They’re also about double the cost over an open one. There's also the question of hauling non-running stuff in and out of an enclosed trailer.

So the alternative is a flat car hauler, one with stake pockets on the sides and build a removable fence to convert to hauling cargo. Probably 3’ sides all around. I’ve seen rigs like that, but they’re not sold that way which means I’d have to build it.

Has anyone done that? Or used one in that config to haul stuff other than cars? I’m thinking that it might be a drag to install/replace the sides and maybe it might be better to just bite the bullet and go enclosed.

Thoughts and perspectives appreciated.
 
Trailers have been part of my life for years now. I can tell you that there's more than weight to consider. The enclosed trailers really take a toll on fuel economy. So much so that I have a 22ft Big Tex flatbed for cars, a "redneck toy hauler" for camping, a light weight homemade tent trailer for shorter trips, and an enclosed utility trailer for smaller jobs. The enclosed trailer weighs 800lbs less than my open, but cuts my fuel economy by 6mpg vs the open car trailer. It's much more noticeable to tow in almost every situation. It does have some advantages when I use it for sparse camping, as I can turn it into shelter. It's nice to lock things up when traveling for overnight trips, and it's nice to just toss stuff in it and close it.
The open trailer is definitely easier to load, easier to tie a car down to, and is the most used trailer in the fleet. I have stake pockets, but have never used them. That is a worthwhile option, if you don't see yourself doing much work that makes the enclosure an option.

I'm also available to tow and drop disabled vehicles. My flatbed has a winch, and can haul a medium sized can and a motorcycle with ease, usually.

I still tell everyone I know to buy an open car trailer. It enables so many other things. Car projects, parts runs, etc. Plus, it keeps them from borrowing mine. If you do buy, don't load it out unless you like re-wiring the plug. It got to the point I might as well cut the plug off before loaning it out, because it would get returned plugless anyway.
 

scootergmc

old and slow
Unless you need the lower profile of a car trailer, I'd recommend an equipment trailer. I'm thinking you need an optioned 10,000 lb. Kaufman deluxe equipment trailer (and only 10,000 based on your tow vehicle). Mount a winch and call it good. FWIW, a family member factory ordered a Kaufman cheaper than the dealer would sell. It was really surprising. He sold it after a few years for more than he paid. Equipment trailers have a weird used market. I've seen them go at auctions for well more than retail. Makes my head itch, so I scratch. Stake pockets make it easy to chain down random things in random places. Since you have property, you'll probably end up using it more often than you think.

https://www.kaufmantrailers.com/equipment-trailers/equipment-trailer/
 

Holeshot

Super Moderator
Staff member
Enclosed trailer all the way. Way more uses...

And take Kyle up on his offer!
 

scootergmc

old and slow
Enclosed trailer all the way. Way more uses.

It depends on those other uses. For me, an enclosed trailer would require another trailer. Ain't no tractors of mine fittin' in an enclosed trailer and being properly secured...:laughing
 

cheez

Master Of The Darkside
+1 to JalopyShoppe's comments. My 16x7 box trailer drops my MPG from 12 to 8 on my 5.9l V8. I'd lend it to you but it's full of household goods I've nowhere else to store right now. :/
 

jt2

Eschew Obfuscation
Thanks guys for the great information and perspectives.

I am leaning towards enclosed since although it will make loading cars a bit more work, it will be more useful in moving loads of stuff up - I won't have to wrestle the sides on/off and worry about covering the load and the wind beating up furniture. Will take weather out of play for trips later in the year as well.

Scooter, your observation on pricing on the used market seems to apply to car haulers as well. Everyone seems to be asking near-new pricing on used. Weird.
 

scootergmc

old and slow
Off the top of your head, how many times do you anticipate using an enclosed trailer because stuff needs to be enclosed? I only ask because it's a lot cheaper renting a box truck or uhaul trailer to move your items needing cover.

I have no experience with Interstate, but there are plenty of trailer buyer's guides out there that show what to watch for, construction, plywood thickness, etc. On a trailer that size, I weep for your 1/2 ton truck. It will be taxed.
 
Top