Edenville Dam collapse Michigan

tzrider

Write Only User
Staff member
That's one way of looking at it, but what were the side effects of lowering the lake levels?

Your link was not without bias, so the article is likely to be for the company and against the governor in it's bias. That needs to be factored into what the article says.

Bias or not, it's pretty common for water management agencies to manipulate lake levels for all kinds of reasons. In this case, if water breached the spillway, it's an argument that they didn't lower levels soon enough.
 

AbsolutEnduser

Throttle Pusher
Was he??????

Michigan Attorney General Nessel and Governor Whitless have their fingerprints all over the massive dam failures that destroyed so much of the Midland area.

Ah! Calling her names, that's the hallmark of any informative post, by A Person Who Knows Better :thumbup

Federal regulators revoked the operating license for the Edenville Dam in September 2018...

So the private owner had no license any more... OK so it doesn't look like a private company is always the better choice then..
 

Maddevill

KNGKAW
Especially in Michigan. Because the UAW killed that whole State.

I keep hoping that some new industry will find a good use for the infrastructure in Detroit and bring it back some.

I have had my eye on Call Centers if they can disincentivize offshoring that work.

UAW didn't kill off anything. The reason we don't have money to fix our crappy infrastructure is that corporations don't have to pay what they should in taxes. The rich either. They have access to loopholes that you and I can' t use. If everyone paid their part, we'd have enough money for the things that need to get done. Blaming it on the union is just doing what they want us to keep doing... which is fight amongst ourselves while they rob us blind.

Mad
 

mrmarklin

Well-known member
The deficiency that they were supposed to fix. It was a hack solution so that they wouldn't have to do required maintenance and improvements, so they can kick the can down the road and maybe some other company would be responsible for it, or the state picks up the tab for fixing it, while they kept all the profits.

I think the point of the article is that the MI government made the company re-fill the lake, leading to the present problem. To supposedly save mussels, or some such. Of course all those mussels are dying now.:wow
 

mrmarklin

Well-known member
Ah! Calling her names, that's the hallmark of any informative post, by A Person Who Knows Better :thumbup



So the private owner had no license any more... OK so it doesn't look like a private company is always the better choice then..

The OP misspelled the governor's name. I think he meant Witless........:rofl
 

UDRider

FLCL?
I think the point of the article is that the MI government made the company re-fill the lake, leading to the present problem. To supposedly save mussels, or some such. Of course all those mussels are dying now.:wow

The point of the article was to shift the blame from root cause: private company deferring maintenance and addressing issues they were aware of. Instead applying bandaid solution to kick the issue down the road where it might be others problem.
 

Climber

Well-known member
The point of the article was to shift the blame from root cause: private company deferring maintenance and addressing issues they were aware of. Instead applying bandaid solution to kick the issue down the road where it might be others problem.
+1

Companies will always take the path to greatest profit, which is exactly why they shouldn't be used for a bunch of places that are traditionally government run.
 

mrmarklin

Well-known member
The point of the article was to shift the blame from root cause: private company deferring maintenance and addressing issues they were aware of. Instead applying bandaid solution to kick the issue down the road where it might be others problem.

You're being deliberately obtuse. I'm done.:x
 

wazzuFreddo

WuTang is 4 the children
You're being deliberately obtuse. I'm done.:x

bye-wellbye-gif-9519446.gif
 

msethhunter

Well-known member
They suck funds away from State. Funds that can be used for infrastructure maintenance. Paying $90k/yr + benefits for non HS-graduates doing manual-labour is outrageous. Not to mention union-fees on top sucking from both sides for union bosses.

WTF does graduating high school have to do with it? Ones potential earnings shouldn't be tied to their level of education. It should be tied to either their skill set and how valuable it is. Thankfully, for the most part, that's true, and the market drives the price. Don't look down your nose at someone just because they didn't attain the same level of education you did. Talk about smug.
 

KooLaid

Hippocritapotamus
WTF does graduating high school have to do with it? Ones potential earnings shouldn't be tied to their level of education. It should be tied to either their skill set and how valuable it is. Thankfully, for the most part, that's true, and the market drives the price. Don't look down your nose at someone just because they didn't attain the same level of education you did. Talk about smug.

One the richest people in my community.....is illiterate. All started with buying one cheap home and never stopping, made his millions upon millions that way.
 
Last edited:

DannoXYZ

Well-known member
WTF does graduating high school have to do with it? Ones potential earnings shouldn't be tied to their level of education. It should be tied to either their skill set and how valuable it is. Thankfully, for the most part, that's true, and the market drives the price. Don't look down your nose at someone just because they didn't attain the same level of education you did. Talk about smug.

One the richest people in my community.....is illiterate. All started with buying one cheap home and never stopping, made his millions upon millions that way.
We're talking about 2 completely different things. You can use outlier examples like Bill Gates or Steve Jobs all you want (both college dropouts). Very few people will be able to get their results by following in their footsteps. But looking at middle of bell-curve will predict the group quite well.

- numerous studies shows difference in bell-curve of non vs. HS-grad. vs college graduates
- German auto-plants have higher % of college grad than anywhere else
- followed by Japanese plants
- takes GM workers ~22-hrs to assemble car in Detroit compared to -16hrs in Toyota Kentucky plant or Honda OH plant
- fewer end-of-line clean-up needed on Toyota or Honda or BMW factory than GM
- fewer product defects in 30, 60, 90-days after sale
- Toyota & Honda plants not unionized as workers don't want it. Employers offer better package than GM+union.
- skill level is tied to educatio. Some of it's formal and some through experience. No one does brain-surgery or robotics design out of the blue. You gotta go through classroom and lots of books along with hands-on training.

Hiring managers know all this stuff and chooses best workers possible for their positions. I'm through with working with people who thinks mailing products to customers wrapped in brown paper-bags with handwritten labels is OK. Or cannabilizing finished cars for parts to complete cars further up line.

Our economy is continually evolving and changing. You have to continually learn new skills to keep up with inflation. Big thing with employers nowadays is certifications in specific new technologies: Cisco, VMware, Linux & Kubernetes, Docker, Puppet, Ansible, etc. Each comes with guaranted compensation schedule.

Review 1994 Hedrick Smith documentary "Challenge to America". Predicts how and why IBM and GM will fall in future as they did. Also " Built to Last" by James Collins.
 
Last edited:

wannabe

"Insignificant Other"
I'm through with working with people who thinks mailing products to customers wrapped in brown paper-bags with handwritten labels is OK. Or cannabilizing finished cars for parts to complete cars further up line.


I've seen fresh off the boat recent college graduates make similar bonehead mistakes. The college degree just means that you're trainable. It does not mean that you will be effective in the job. (This is coming from a guy with an engineering degree.)

Given a choice between someone who spent 5 years getting their degree or someone who spent 5 years without a degree working as a tech in the industry, I'll take experience over the piece of paper every time.

And, the difference between GM and the Japanese/German plants has very little to do with the percentage of employees with college degrees. As people keep saying here, correlation does not imply causation.
 

tzrider

Write Only User
Staff member
WTF does graduating high school have to do with it? Ones potential earnings shouldn't be tied to their level of education. It should be tied to either their skill set and how valuable it is. Thankfully, for the most part, that's true, and the market drives the price. Don't look down your nose at someone just because they didn't attain the same level of education you did. Talk about smug.

Well, income historically has correlated to education most of the time. The phrase "non HS-graduates doing manual-labour" should tell you something about the nature of the work being performed. Manual labor usually refers to relatively unskilled labor. These jobs are important to get done but there is an ample supply of people who can do them and they tend to not pay a lot.

That's not smug, it's supply and demand.
 

ejv

Untitled work in progress
+1

Companies will always take the path to greatest profit, which is exactly why they shouldn't be used for a bunch of places that are traditionally government run.

Governments have been known to do the same. Magalia Reservoir has been dropped permanently about 25 ft since 1996 due to its need for seismic retrofitting and nobody wanting to pay for it.

A group of people brought to the attention of the federal energy regulatory commission in 2005 concerns over the emergency spillway at Oroville Dam. The fix was supposed to be $100M which was ruled unnecessary and too costly. That eventually led to the poor outcome from the crisis there in 2017 which has cost over $1B in repairs.
 
Top