Saline Valley Warm Springs Management Plan

ThumperX

Well-known member
Saline Valley Warm Springs Needs our help!!!

Off the AMA radar but in the gun sights of the National Park Service I am pleading with my fellow riders to please take action.

Several plans are being proposed for Saline Valley from the leave it and do nothing (as good as it sounds it isn't the safest plan) to total restoration.

As a member of the Saline Preservation Assosiation I urge you to take a moment and see what is being proposed for this amazing piece of American Landscape.

This is an email I received last night from Major Tom who runs the SalinePreservation association.

Saline Preservation Association membership@salinepreservation.org

7:37 PM (16 hours ago)

to SPA

Dear Members,


While I was in Kauai, I heard of the Park Service scheduling public meetings and initiating a comment period on the proposed alternatives for the Saline Valley Management Plan. The NPS did not notify me of these dates, as they usually do, before I left for this two-week vacation in Hawaii. (Mike Cipra was my contact, and he said he is leaving the employ of the Park Service, so this may explain the failure in communication.) I have just returned home, where I now have access to the SPA database and can inform our membership of these events at the 11th hour. My apologies for a situation over which I had little control. This email alert is somewhat scatter-shot, but I felt it important to get something out as quickly as possible, and will do a follow up after the upcoming meetings. -Major Tom

Here is the gist of the NPS invitation taken directly from their website:

Alternatives Development

The National Park Service (NPS) is seeking public input to help inform and shape alternatives development for a management plan and environmental impact statement for the Saline Valley Warm Springs area of Death Valley National Park (Park). Five alternatives have been drafted and the Park Service is asking for comments at three public meetings in February. Comments can also be submitted electronically or by mail.

The purpose of the proposed plan is to provide a basis for managing this remote yet popular area of the park, balancing the protection of unique natural and cultural resources with public health and visitor use at the Saline Valley Warm Springs.

Public input is important to this planning process, and the NPS encourages participation at the open house style public meetings at the Park and in gateway communities on February 4-6, 2014. The NPS will present the elements of the preliminary alternatives and provide opportunity for attendees to comment on these and other reasonable options for the planning process. The agency is asking for detailed comments on specific elements of an alternative(s) to help guide the Park in refining the alternatives.



Comments can be made at: http://parkplanning.nps.gov/document...cumentID=56823

Comment Period: 01/23/2014 - 03/28/2014

Following the above-provided link will give you access to the Alternatives and similarly relevant documents. The alternatives range from "No Action" to Complete removal of all the tubs, sinks and non-native landscaping we have enjoyed for decades.

Public meetings have been scheduled for Feb 4 at Furnace Creek, Feb 5 in Lone Pine, and Feb 6 in Ridgecrest. All meetings take place between 4-6:30 p.m.

More information on locations, and directions, may be found at: http://parkplanning.nps.gov/meetingN...rojectID=39438

If anyone needs a place to camp in Ridgecrest, I have lots of room and invite you to use our yard. Just drop me a return email for more information.

I would encourage our members to share your comments to the NPS with the Saline Preservation Association, so that we might best represent the views of our membership in offering a SPA position paper with respect to the Park's suggested Management Plan options.

If you would care to comment on the process being used by the Park Service to gather comments and public input with respect to the Saline Valley Management Plan, we would welcome that input as well, and will present those comments to the Park.

Any comments you care to share should be emailed to: membership@salinepreservation.org

I would like to share a relevant post offered by our member Timothy Sutherland:

Two of the guiding principles the National Park Service adheres to:http://www.americantrails.org/resour...PSmission.html

* Productive Partnerships: Collaborating with federal, state, tribal, and local governments, private organizations (that's us), and businesses to work toward common goals.
* Citizen Involvement: Providing opportunities for citizens to participate in the decisions and actions of the National Park Service.

I really hope they believe in these guiding principles. The second really speaks to us. I can only imagine how many comments are being sent to the NPS during this comment period of which I would think 99% would be in favor of keeping things the way they are as we are by far the largest group of people who use and protect this area.


Again, I am sorry this information may be reaching you at past the 11th hour for the public meetings, but public comments made online are welcome through March 28.
 

ThumperX

Well-known member
Latest from Major Tom:
He has a special note regarding comments that I have highlighted.

Greetings friends,



Here is the latest installment of what will be an ongoing series of mails relating to the DEVA Saline Valley Warm Springs Management Plan EIS as can be reviewed at: http://parkplanning.nps.gov/document.cfm?parkID=297&projectID=39438&documentID=56823 If you are new to this mailing list, and want some of the previous emails, let me know. There may be a few of you.



I recently attended the Ridgecrest public meeting where park staff and the public had an opportunity to speak and exchange ideas face to face. I used the opportunity to help clarify what I thought were a few ambiguous issues within the Management Elements and proposed alternatives offered. I have once again attached a copy of this table for your easy review.



There is a lot to discuss, and I will bring up a limited number of points in each upcoming email so as to not overwhelm the reader.



· Firstly, there are 29 different elements to the proposed management plan. There are five management alternatives for each element ranging from NO ACTION to RESTORATION at each end of this series.

· We can, and MUST mix and match alternatives to elements. Many people are commenting: TAKE NO ACTION and leaving it at that. It is not possible for the NPS to take NO ACTION as there are certain issues at the springs that currently violate the law and/or health codes. I will discuss some of these at greater length later.

· If you say: TAKE NO ACTION and nothing more substantive is offered in the way of constructive suggestion, it is as good as saying nothing, and the NPS will then take whatever action it deems appropriate.

· You will maximize your input if you make constructive comments on each element in the EIS. I was able to talk at length with Kathy Billings, the Park Superintendent, and she encourages us to identify what is important and special to your experience of Saline Valley and to memorialize it. Let the Park know how you want to experience Saline Valley in the future. If you give them constructive suggestions (rather than "do Nothing"; "It aint broke, don’t fix it", etc.) then we are being proactive toward creating the environment we want to see. The impression I get is that the Park is interested in our input. We can only hope and all we can do is all we can do.


· You will be able to offer more than one set of comments. Comment early, comment often. This has relevance as we continue to educate ourselves on the issue and form a "consolidated" position.

· We need more time to explore the options, educate ourselves on a number of aspects within the plan. We CAN ask for an extension on the comment period, which currently ends on March 28. Kathy Billings has asked that SPA enter such a request on behalf of our members. Please vote on whether you want to see an extension or not at: http://forum.salinepreservation.org...t-plan-draft-alternatives-6667416?trail=90#79 There is lots of good discussion going on at this forum too. Look for that discussion to expand in the future.



That is enough and all for now. Look for more mails soon. Hope you are all reading these in full!



All we can do is all we can do.


Major Tom

Proposed plans for Saline Warm Springs
 
Some issues the Feds are concerned about ...

• Human use of the springs for rec- reational activities could alter the quality of the water in the spring by impacting the geothermal source pool microorganisms and ecosys- tems.

• Alteration of the water flow could have an impact on the quantity of water at the source springs and on water flow in the surrounding des- ert washes.

• Activities associated with the rec- reational use of the warm springs and the surrounding non-wilderness area are spreading into adjacent wilderness areas; some of these ac- tivities may be inconsistent with the Wilderness Act of 1964.

• Non-native plant species have been introduced at the springs, altering the natural vegetation community in the area.

• The burro population may com- pete with native species for re- sources.

• Off-road driving and dispersed, unregulated camping surrounding the three springs results in distur- bance to soils and other geologi- cal resources.

• Diversion of water at the springs for an extended period of time could be impacting natural hydro- logical processes.
 
More concerns ...

Cultural Resorces
• Archeological resources have been impacted by visitor activities, such as disturbing or collecting artifacts or creating social trails through sites.

• RecreationaluseoftheSalineValley Warm Springs could be impacting a special use area as well as a cultural resource preservation area for the Timbisha Shoshone Tribe.

Visitor Experience
• Becauseoftheremotenessofthe area, Park staff is not able to have continuous presence and provide ad- equate service to visitors.

• The size of the groups that use the springs is variable and unregulat- ed, leading to potential tensions between users.

• The large peace symbols that have been created within the surround- ing wilderness can be seen from vari- ous distances within the Saline Valley viewshed.

• Not all Park visitors would feel welcome to Warm Springs under current management policies.

•Due to the harsh conditions in Death Valley National Park, human health and safety in remote areas is a concern.

• While cleaning of the soaking pools is handled by volunteers, maintenance is unregulated.

• Also unregulated is the storage of potentially hazardous substances (e.g., cleaning solutions, gasoline) and the runoff from the soaking pools and the dishwashing station.

Park Operations
• Because of the size of the Park and the remoteness of the area, it is difficult to provide continuous operation support.

• Users of the Warm Springs self-manage the area with assistance from a volunteer, which could con- flict with customary NPS management practices.
 
Top