Michelle Carter suicide-by-text manslaughter trial

msethhunter

Well-known member
She might be a sick human being, but she'll probably get off. I just don't see how this can be considered manslaughter.

And her attorney was smart in going for a judge trial, not a jury trial.
 

bojangle

FN # 40
Staff member
She might be a sick human being, but she'll probably get off. I just don't see how this can be considered manslaughter.

And her attorney was smart in going for a judge trial, not a jury trial.

Yup, totally! They will challenge the legal elements of homicide, not emotions from a jury.

I'm trying to figure out what the hell was in it for her. Like, is this something related to Munchausen syndrome by proxy for her? I'm not quite understanding her angle.
 

ScarySpikes

tastes like burning
She might be a sick human being, but she'll probably get off. I just don't see how this can be considered manslaughter.

And her attorney was smart in going for a judge trial, not a jury trial.

Yea, manslaughter is killing someone without premeditation or intent. If you are going to call this murder, it is definitely premeditated and shows intent.

Girl deserves to live in a cell for sure.
 

byke

Well-known member
It's bad to hit girls, but I'd make an exception for her. Water, cliff bars and no-doze, because it'd be a long day.
 

Butch

poseur
Staff member
Most folks do not understand how consuming and debilitating depression can be. For years, for a lifetime. Yeah, they have drugs, but then peeps are just doped up.

I have no idea what the answer is, but untill you have been there, it is dificult to understand. Compassion helps.
 

TylerW

Agitator
Most folks do not understand how consuming and debilitating depression can be. For years, for a lifetime. Yeah, they have drugs, but then peeps are just doped up.

I have no idea what the answer is, but untill you have been there, it is dificult to understand. Compassion helps.

Absolutely this. it takes all the courage in the world to admit that you have been considering suicide, because it's a good, hard look at your own self in the mirror.

This woman took that trust and weaponized it.
 

Butch

poseur
Staff member
Remember, teenagers are insane. Some of the folks here who are parents can attest to that.
 

asdfghwy

Well-known member
Remember, teenagers are insane. Some of the folks here who are parents can attest to that.

I think there's standard crazy / rebellious rowdy teenagers and then there's encouraging and egging on the suicide of your "boyfriend".


After his death she tried to play it off like she was so sad and that she was a victim too.
 
Last edited:

Kim

It’s cold in Colorado
She was looking for attention. No one cares if your bf is depressed and suicidal especially in hs. Have a bf commit suicide then all of a sudden EVERYONE wants to talk to you, be around you and you're the center of attention. thats why she encouraged him and played the sad card.
 

Cycle61

What the shit is this...
Disturbing how coherent and normal that entire conversation sounded. Like they were making dinner plans or setting up a visit to a counselor.

Wow.
 
Top