Hey Cincinnatus,
If you haven't already committed to the BMW GSA, you should look into the KTM 1290 Super Adventure S. Coming from sportbike, dirt. Supermoto , and adventure background i purchased a 2018 GSA. She is a great bike, would take you to hell and back. I know this from experience. Is capable of riding way beyond mere mortal skillset. I found that when riding with fast sportbikes, I was loosing grounds on the straights. I can keep up with majority of riders but the GSA tops out about 120 with full panniers. Might not be a priority for you since you will be riding in dirt. Another pro to the KTM 1290 adventure is the weight difference. Alot lighter than a GSA. Slap after market skid plate, adventure tires, and some crash bars she will kick ass in the dirt. Also GSA alot more expensive.
I am committed to the GSA, so there's that. I grew up on Yamahas, had a KZ1100A3 rescue that I never loved (it never loved me back, so there's that), then got the K1200R that's now too expensive to fix, and I've been riding since 1978 or so. Lots of street miles, if there's a group ride I sweep it. I do love the acceleration and speed, but I do like the control. I've ridden a 990 KTM and it's a pure blast, I know where you're coming from. I want to take mine camping, fishing, and exploring all over the place, and I'm pretty sure the GSA will be right for me. Yeah, I know it's a heavy beast, but that goes with the territory, and I'm ok with that.
I thought i was a true BMW guy when I got mine. Unfortunately I lost my BMW GSA to the Paradise "Camp Fire" last year. After some serious soul searching , youtube research, and what I really wanted in a bike. I chose the KTM 1290 Super Adventure S. Only small difference between the R/S model. Wheel size, some suspension component and crash bars. Did I mention the KTM has 160 HP compared to GSA 125 Hp. Almost identical electronics.
Not trying to change your mind, just some constructive feedback. Also if you do decide on the GSA I still have my brand new BMW NAV VI I might be willing to give you a hell of a deal on. Just got a new one from Garmin after some screen issue. Nov 7, 2018. She only has 1 trip ride on her. You can see my route from Paradise to Chico, then from Chico to Paradise. First and last ride on Nov 8, 2018.
I'm really glad you survived the Paradise fire, is your family up there too and how are they? I had a friend who lived up there with his wife & daughter, they were able to GTFO before their house burnt down to the ground. He had his rifles, a great model train setup, lots of nice stuff. He & family are now down in Boca Raton, FL, and will never come back to CA. Too many memories, lost friends, etc... Yeah, interested in the Nav 6, but retail is $950, so unless it's a smoking deal, I can use my Android. Yeah, I know it integrates into the TFT and all that, but I'm a student at Cal Hayward. Not broke, but not rolling in dough. :teeth
My truck got sideswiped by some jerk a month ago and I rented a 1250GS from Dubbelju for the week my truck was getting fixed. Really nice bike, handled very nicely, great acceleration, brakes, etc. Didn't have time to play with the cruise control or any of the ESA ride modes, tho. Did go up & down on Redwood Road down here a few times, it's a blast...
Thanks for the input, I do appreciate it! :thumbup